Make the Caramel Sauce
Melt 0.75 cups granulated sugar over medium high heat in a saucepan, stirring occasionally to prevent the caramel from forming toffee. Once the sugar has melted to a “deep golden caramel,” (pg. 255), remove the pot from the stovetop.
Gradually pour 1.5 cups whole milk to the caramel, stirring “carefully” to prevent clumped caramel and curdled milk due to the temperature differences. Replace the saucepan over moderate heat and stir until the caramel has completely dissolved. The caramel will take on a cappuccino color and texture. Allow the caramel sauce to cool.
Make the Custard
In a medium sauce pan, whisk 3 egg yolks with a pinch of salt and 3 tbsp cornstarch (to help bind the yolks.

Gradually pour the caramel sauce into the bowl, allowing the milk, eggs and sugar to form a custard-like base for the ice cream.

Heat the saucepan over high heat, until the mixture boils. Allow the custard to boil for 2 minutes remove from heat. The eggs and cornstarch have thickened the caramel sauce.

McQueary advises straining the mixture through a fine sieve, however my custard was clump-free.
Set Up Icebath
Fill a large mixing bowl with water and ice cubes.
Transfer custard to a metal bowl, place bowl in ice bath to cool. The metal will help evenly lower the temperature of the custard. Stir the ingredients while they cool, so they remain blended.
Make the Ice Cream
Mix 1.5 tsp vanilla extract with 1.5 cups heavy cream, then add to the custard, which at this time has cooled to room temperature in the ice bath. Pour mixture into the ice cream maker and blend for 25 minutes, until the cream is cold and formed.


Caramel custard before churning in the ice cream maker
I found stirring the ingredients in a metal bowl in the ice bath helped jump start the ice cream churning. I noticed the cream formed a soft serve consistency within 11 minutes in the ice cream .maker. What a great trick! The ice cream is smooth, creamy and sweet. Set ice cream in the freezer, then prepare the crust.

Churned caramel ice cream, silky, cold with a soft serve consistency
Make the Crust


In a food processor, pulse 1.5 cups (about 9 oz) gingersnap cookies. You may use Ann Richards’ Gingersnap Cookies. Add 1 cup granulated sugar and pulse in the food processor. Pour dry ingredients into a bowl, add 1 oz (2 tbsp) softened butter (about 15 seconds nuked in the microwave). Butter will bind the cookie crumbs to mold the pie crust. Mold the crumbs around a buttered 9 inch pie tin, using squeaky clean hands (Hannah Swenson reference) to evenly pat down the crumbs.. Bake the crust at 350F for 8-10 minutes (10 minutes worked for me). Chill crust in the freezer until set (about half an hour).

Melt 1 tbsp butter and 0.75 cups semisweet chocolate chips in a saucepan. Pour melted chocolate around the pie crust’s base, distribute evenly with a pastry brush. I made the mistake of melting the cholate in a microwave, causing it to clump and difficult to spread around the pie crust. Chill the chocolate covered crust in the freezer, until set, about 10 minutes. Remove the set ice cream from freezer and warm the outside of the ice cream bowl’s base with warm water, loosening the ice cream. Use a rubber spatula to transfer the ice cream from the bowl to the crust, the evenly distribute atop the set chocolate. Return the pie to the freezer for 3 hours, so the ice cream may set in the crust.
Garnish the ice cream pie with whipped cream and candied oranges. I substituted candied oranges for candied ginger.























































